{ "generated_at": "2026-09-10T18:00:57+00:00", "public_policy": "page_specific_aggregates_and_identifier_free_debate_comment_text", "files": [ { "file": "data/contextual_summary_by_video.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-summary-full-20260822-b150-w2/results/video_contextual_reclassification_summary.csv", "rows": 30, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "comments", "contextual_classified", "contextual_failed", "contextual_not_run_no_transcript", "contextual_not_run_no_summary", "transcript_segments", "transcript_characters", "context_sha256", "contextual_legitimacy__자격부정·배제", "contextual_legitimacy__조건부수용", "contextual_legitimacy__수용·지지", "contextual_legitimacy__혼합·상충", "contextual_legitimacy__중립·기타", "contextual_eligibility__환자·고도비만 자격", "contextual_eligibility__정상체중·미용 목적", "contextual_eligibility__조건부 사용 허용", "contextual_eligibility__질환·적응증", "contextual_tone__긍정·감사", "contextual_tone__비판·불신", "contextual_tone__우려·불안", "contextual_tone__질문·정보요청", "contextual_tone__중립·기타", "legitimacy_changed_vs_direct_rate", "tone_changed_vs_direct_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_summary_distributions.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-summary-full-20260822-b150-w2/results/contextual_reclassification_distributions.csv", "rows": 420, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "construct", "label", "classified_comments", "count", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_verification_by_video_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-full-verification-20260822/results/video_contextual_reclassification_summary.csv", "rows": 29, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "comments", "contextual_classified", "contextual_failed", "contextual_not_run_no_transcript", "contextual_not_run_no_summary", "transcript_segments", "transcript_characters", "context_sha256", "contextual_legitimacy__자격부정·배제", "contextual_legitimacy__조건부수용", "contextual_legitimacy__수용·지지", "contextual_legitimacy__혼합·상충", "contextual_legitimacy__중립·기타", "contextual_eligibility__환자·고도비만 자격", "contextual_eligibility__정상체중·미용 목적", "contextual_eligibility__조건부 사용 허용", "contextual_eligibility__질환·적응증", "contextual_tone__긍정·감사", "contextual_tone__비판·불신", "contextual_tone__우려·불안", "contextual_tone__질문·정보요청", "contextual_tone__중립·기타", "legitimacy_changed_vs_direct_rate", "tone_changed_vs_direct_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_verification_distributions.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-full-verification-20260822/results/contextual_reclassification_distributions.csv", "rows": 406, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "construct", "label", "classified_comments", "count", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_verification_agreement.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-full-verification-20260822/results/verification_comparison/verification_summary.csv", "rows": 4, "columns": [ "construct", "summary_rows", "full_rows", "matched_rows", "agreement_rate", "changed_rows" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_verification_by_video.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-full-verification-20260822/results/verification_comparison/verification_by_video.csv", "rows": 29, "columns": [ "video_id", "matched_rows", "contextual_legitimacy_changed_rows", "contextual_legitimacy_agreement_rate", "contextual_eligibility_labels_changed_rows", "contextual_eligibility_labels_agreement_rate", "contextual_tone_changed_rows", "contextual_tone_agreement_rate", "any_construct_changed_rows", "any_construct_agreement_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_mode_efficiency.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_efficiency_comparison/efficiency_comparison.csv", "rows": 6, "columns": [ "mode", "batch_size", "summary_chars_target", "comments", "classifier_batches", "summary_prepass_calls", "total_calls", "repeated_context_chars", "prompt_chars", "max_prompt_chars" ] }, { "file": "data/contextual_mode_agreement.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_efficiency_comparison/verification_mode_agreement/verification_mode_agreement.csv", "rows": 3, "columns": [ "construct", "full_rows", "summary_rows", "matched_rows", "agreement_rate", "changed_rows" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_summary_index.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_transcript_summaries/transcript-summary-full-20260822/summary_index.csv", "rows": 29, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "full_context_characters", "summary_characters", "compression_ratio", "reduction_rate", "full_context_sha256", "summary_sha256" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_category_comparison.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/transcript_comment_comparison/data/category_comparison.csv", "rows": 4, "columns": [ "category", "videos", "comments", "transcript_segments", "mean_micro_cosine", "median_micro_cosine", "mean_top5_jaccard" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_video_comparison.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/transcript_comment_comparison/data/video_comparison.csv", "rows": 29, "columns": [ "plan_no", "video_id", "category", "channel", "video_title", "drug_keyword", "transcript_file", "transcript_segments", "transcript_characters", "transcript_duration_seconds", "comments", "micro_profile_cosine", "top5_jaccard", "transcript_top5", "comment_top5", "largest_comment_over_video_gap", "largest_video_over_comment_gap", "largest_positive_gap", "largest_negative_gap" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_micro_gaps.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/transcript_comment_comparison/data/micro_gaps.csv", "rows": 609, "columns": [ "plan_no", "video_id", "category", "video_title", "macro", "meso", "micro_label", "transcript_rate", "comment_rate", "comment_minus_transcript" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_overall_micro.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/transcript_comment_comparison/data/overall_micro.csv", "rows": 21, "columns": [ "macro", "meso", "micro_label", "videos", "mean_transcript_rate", "mean_comment_rate", "mean_comment_minus_transcript" ] }, { "file": "data/debate_video_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/video_debate_analysis/data/video_debate_summary.csv", "rows": 30, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "drug_group", "all_comments", "all_threads", "reply_comments", "threads_with_replies", "threads_2plus", "debate_threads", "debate_thread_comments", "debate_thread_replies", "debate_threads_2plus", "max_replies_in_debate_thread", "direct_conflict_comments", "debate_thread_share_of_threads", "debate_thread_comment_share_of_video", "direct_conflict_comment_share_of_video", "direct_conflict_share_of_replies", "debate_continuation_rate", "conflict_share_of_debate_replies", "mean_replies_per_debate_thread", "debate_intensity", "topic_count", "topics" ] }, { "file": "data/debate_topics.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/video_debate_analysis/data/video_debate_topics.csv", "rows": 478, "columns": [ "video_id", "topic", "topic_participating_comments", "topic_threads", "topic_direct_conflict_comments", "topic_threads_2plus", "all_comments", "all_threads", "debate_threads", "debate_thread_comments", "direct_conflict_comments", "debate_thread_replies", "macro", "meso", "topic_thread_share_of_video_threads", "topic_participating_share_of_video", "topic_share_of_debate_comments", "topic_continuation_rate", "topic_conflict_share", "topic_conflict_rate_within_comments", "topic_signal", "video_title", "category", "drug_group" ] }, { "file": "data/integrated_contextual_distributions.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_legitimacy_analysis/data/contextual_distributions.csv", "rows": 1260, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "construct", "source", "label", "rate", "count", "denominator", "content_available" ] }, { "file": "data/integrated_source_group_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_legitimacy_analysis/data/source_group_summary.csv", "rows": 42, "columns": [ "construct", "source", "label", "videos", "mean_rate", "median_rate", "pooled_count", "pooled_denominator", "pooled_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/integrated_video_contextual_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_legitimacy_analysis/data/video_contextual_summary.csv", "rows": 30, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "all_comments", "transcript_available", "transcript_segments", "transcript_characters", "legitimacy_content_primary", "legitimacy_comment_primary", "legitimacy_integrated_primary", "legitimacy_relation", "legitimacy_total_variation_gap", "eligibility_content_primary", "eligibility_comment_primary", "eligibility_integrated_primary", "eligibility_relation", "eligibility_total_variation_gap", "tone_content_primary", "tone_comment_primary", "tone_integrated_primary", "tone_relation", "tone_total_variation_gap" ] }, { "file": "data/topic_codebook.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/refined_topic_codebook.csv", "rows": 20, "columns": [ "topic_id", "research_label", "broad_theme", "label_confidence" ] }, { "file": "data/topic_overall.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/refined_topic_overall.csv", "rows": 20, "columns": [ "broad_theme", "research_label", "comments", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/topic_prevalence.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/refined_topic_prevalence.csv", "rows": 80, "columns": [ "category", "broad_theme", "research_label", "comments", "mean_probability", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/argument_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/argument_summary.csv", "rows": 36, "columns": [ "category", "primary_argument_role", "comments", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/argument_legitimacy_cross.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/argument_legitimacy_cross.csv", "rows": 42, "columns": [ "final_legitimacy", "primary_argument_role", "comments", "within_legitimacy_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/experience_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/experience_summary.csv", "rows": 99, "columns": [ "category", "drug_group", "event", "comments", "self_report_candidates", "all_comments", "event_rate" ] }, { "file": "data/experience_transitions.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/experience_transitions.csv", "rows": 90, "columns": [ "source_event", "target_event", "comments" ] }, { "file": "data/question_gap_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/question_gap_summary.csv", "rows": 306, "columns": [ "category", "primary_question_theme", "question_intent", "response_status", "questions", "theme_questions", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/stigma_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/stigma_summary.csv", "rows": 12, "columns": [ "category", "severity_label", "comments", "all_comments", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/stigma_target_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/stigma_target_summary.csv", "rows": 19, "columns": [ "category", "target", "comments" ] }, { "file": "data/dialogue_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/dialogue_summary.csv", "rows": 32, "columns": [ "category", "primary_dialogue_act", "pairs", "constructive_candidates", "conflict_candidates", "rate" ] }, { "file": "data/claim_reference_coverage.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/claim_reference_coverage.csv", "rows": 7, "columns": [ "claim_type", "candidate_mentions", "reference_ids", "first_review", "additional_review", "automatic_truth_verdict" ] }, { "file": "data/claim_review_matrix.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/claim_review_matrix.csv", "rows": 7, "columns": [ "claim_type", "reference_ids", "first_review", "additional_review", "automatic_truth_verdict" ] }, { "file": "data/safety_claim_summary.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/safety_claim_summary.csv", "rows": 54, "columns": [ "category", "claim_type", "evidence_marker_present", "comments" ] }, { "file": "data/transcript_category_alignment.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/transcript_category_alignment.csv", "rows": 4, "columns": [ "category", "videos", "mean_micro_cosine", "median_micro_cosine", "mean_top5_jaccard" ] }, { "file": "data/video_frame_alignment.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/video_frame_alignment.csv", "rows": 29, "columns": [ "video_id", "category", "transcript_segments", "transcript_characters", "comments", "micro_profile_cosine", "top5_jaccard", "transcript_top5", "comment_top5" ] }, { "file": "data/video_frame_gaps.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/video_frame_gaps.csv", "rows": 609, "columns": [ "video_id", "category", "micro_label", "transcript_rate", "comment_rate", "comment_minus_transcript" ] }, { "file": "data/official_medical_references.csv", "source": "output/additional_analysis/data/official_medical_references.csv", "rows": 4, "columns": [ "reference_id", "authority", "product", "document", "jurisdiction", "review_topics", "url", "use_limit" ] } ], "source_runs": { "summary_reclassification": "contextual-summary-full-20260822-b150-w2", "full_verification": "contextual-full-verification-20260822", "transcript_summary": "transcript-summary-full-20260822", "additional_analysis_generated_at": "2026-08-21T07:44:29+00:00", "video_debate_stance": "stance-full-20260822", "astra_revalidation": "astra-validation-20260910" }, "scope": { "comments": 22635, "videos": 30, "transcript_videos": 29, "transcript_segments": 8176, "summary_classified": 22000, "full_verification_classified": 3955 }, "verification": { "summary_labels": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-summary-full-20260822-b150-w2/results/contextual_comment_labels.csv", "full_verification_labels": "output/additional_analysis/contextual_comment_reclassification/contextual-full-verification-20260822/results/contextual_comment_labels.csv", "matched_rows": 3955, "summary_rows": 22000, "full_rows": 3955, "changed_any_construct_rows": 1798, "unchanged_all_construct_rows": 2157, "video_count": 29, "mean_summary_confidence": 0.9238331226295828, "mean_full_confidence": 0.9281542351453856, "constructs": [ { "construct": "contextual_legitimacy", "summary_rows": 22000, "full_rows": 3955, "matched_rows": 3955, "agreement_rate": 0.7936788874841972, "changed_rows": 816 }, { "construct": "contextual_eligibility_labels", "summary_rows": 22000, "full_rows": 3955, "matched_rows": 3955, "agreement_rate": 0.8412136536030341, "changed_rows": 628 }, { "construct": "contextual_tone", "summary_rows": 22000, "full_rows": 3955, "matched_rows": 3955, "agreement_rate": 0.7431099873577749, "changed_rows": 1016 }, { "construct": "any_construct", "summary_rows": 22000, "full_rows": 3955, "matched_rows": 3955, "agreement_rate": 0.5453855878634639, "changed_rows": 1798 } ], "note": "전체 대본 재분류는 요약 대본 결과의 quality_review_required 또는 confidence<0.80 후보에만 수행한 검증 단계이며, 22,000개 전체의 전체 대본 재분류를 의미하지 않음." }, "video_debate_stance": { "policy": "aggregate_only_no_comment_text_or_comment_identifiers", "source_rows": 843, "classified_rows": 843, "files": [ { "file": "data/debate_stance_video_summary.csv", "rows": 30, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "pair_count", "thread_count", "topic_count", "dominant_relation", "dominant_position_across_sides", "relation_distribution", "position_distribution_across_sides", "top_topics", "mean_confidence" ] }, { "file": "data/debate_stance_topic_summary.csv", "rows": 411, "columns": [ "video_id", "video_title", "category", "topic", "pair_count", "thread_count", "parent_comment_count", "reply_comment_count", "dominant_parent_position", "dominant_parent_position_count", "dominant_reply_position", "dominant_reply_position_count", "parent_position_distribution", "reply_position_distribution", "relation_distribution", "dominant_relation", "dominant_issue", "mean_confidence" ] }, { "file": "data/debate_stance_summary.json", "rows": null, "columns": [ "classified_rows", "generated_at", "model", "positions", "prompt_version", "provider", "relations", "source_rows", "topics", "videos" ] } ] }, "video_dossiers": { "policy": "aggregate_only_no_comment_text_or_comment_identifiers", "source": "output/video_dossiers", "files": [ "video_index.csv", "video_label_distributions.csv", "video_debate_topic_distribution.csv", "video_contextual_summary.csv", "video_frame_alignment.csv", "video_transcript_comparison.csv" ], "videos": 30, "video_topic_rows": 478 }, "debate_browser": { "policy": "debate_thread_comment_text_without_comment_or_author_identifiers", "path": "analysis/debate-browser.html", "data": "data/debate_browser_data.json", "videos": 30, "debate_comments": 5265, "topic_rows": 478 }, "astra_revalidation": { "policy": "aggregate_only", "path": "analysis/astra-revalidation.html", "data": "data/astra_revalidation.json", "source_run": "astra-validation-20260910", "model": "gpt-6-astra", "rows": 600, "human_subset_rows": 200, "human_validation_performed": false, "files": [ "data/astra_agreement_metrics.csv", "data/astra_cohort_summary.csv", "data/astra_category_metrics.csv", "data/astra_micro_label_metrics.csv", "data/astra_label_transitions.csv", "data/astra_public_summary.xlsx" ] } }